馃┖

Medigap vs Medicare Advantage Calculator

Compare your 2027 yearly cost: Original Medicare + Medigap + Part D vs a Medicare Advantage plan

Enter the premiums you were quoted and your Medicare Advantage plan's cost sharing. The calculator adds the Part B premium ($2,513 a year at the 2027 rate of $209.40 a month), plan premiums, and what you would pay for care in a healthy, moderate and major year. Prescription drug costs are left out because both options include Part D with the same $2,400 yearly cap.

Original Medicare + Medigap
$

Your quote; varies by state, age, sex, tobacco use and insurer

$

From Medicare Plan Finder; the 2027 national base premium is $41.33

Medicare Advantage (with drugs)
$

Many plans charge $0; you still pay the Part B premium

$

Part B premium reduction, if your plan offers one

$

Many plans have $0

%

Copays as a share of costs; 20% is a common estimate

$

From your plan; the 2027 federal limit is $9,850

$

Medicare-approved cost of your care for the year, excluding drugs

2027 year of careMedigap Plan GMedicare AdvantageCheaper
Healthy year ($2,000 of care: checkups, labs, a few visits)$5,085$2,913Advantage by $2,172
Moderate year ($10,000 of care: specialists, imaging, outpatient procedure)$5,085$4,513Advantage by $572
Major year ($50,000 of care: hospital stay, surgery, or cancer treatment)$5,085$12,363Medigap by $7,278
Break-even point: Medicare Advantage is cheaper until your care costs about $12,860 in a year; above that, Medigap wins. Fixed costs before any care: Medigap side $4,793, Advantage side $2,513.
Worst case (a very expensive year): Medigap Plan G $5,085; Medicare Advantage $12,363 in network (PPO out-of-network care can reach a combined $14,800 limit).

Disclaimer: This calculator provides estimates for educational and informational purposes only. It does not constitute tax, legal, financial, or medical advice. Results depend on individual circumstances and may not reflect your actual costs. Always consult a qualified professional (CPA, licensed insurance agent, or financial advisor) for decisions about your specific situation. Data reflects approximate 2026 figures from IRS, CMS, and HHS sources.

Medigap vs Medicare Advantage: The Cost Trade-Off

Original Medicare (Parts A and B) has no yearly out-of-pocket limit: after the Part B deductible you pay 20% of most outpatient care, and each hospital stay starts with the Part A deductible ($1,776 per benefit period in 2027). There are two ways to limit that exposure:

  • Original Medicare + Medigap + a Part D plan. You pay higher, predictable premiums, and the Medigap policy pays most or all of the 20%. You can see any doctor or hospital in the US that accepts Medicare, with no referrals or network.
  • Medicare Advantage (Part C). A private plan replaces Original Medicare, usually with drug coverage included and often a $0 plan premium. You pay copays as you use care, up to the plan's out-of-pocket maximum, and most plans use a network and prior authorization.

So the cheaper choice depends on your year: Advantage tends to win when you use little care, Medigap when you use a lot. The calculator above finds the point where they cross.

2027Medigap Plan GMedigap Plan NHigh-deductible Plan GMedicare Advantage
You pay before coveragePart B deductible ($292)Part B deductible + up to $20 office / $50 ER copays$3,050 deductiblePlan copays and coinsurance
Yearly limit on medical costsNone needed after the deductibleNo cap on copays; excess charges not covered$3,050Up to $9,850 in network ($14,800 combined for PPOs)
Drug coverageSeparate Part D plan (premium extra)Usually included
DoctorsAny provider in the US that accepts MedicarePlan network; referrals and prior authorization common
PremiumsPart B + Medigap + Part DPart B + plan premium (often $0)

Worked Examples (2027)

Medigap side: Plan G at $150 a month plus a $40 Part D plan. Advantage side: a $0-premium plan with drug coverage, no medical deductible, copays that average 20% of the cost of care, and a $9,850 in-network maximum. Both pay the Part B premium: $209.40 x 12 = $2,513.

1. Healthy year, $2,000 of care. Medigap: $2,513 + $1,800 + $480 in premiums + the $292 Part B deductible = $5,085. Advantage: $2,513 + 20% x $2,000 = $2,913. Advantage saves $2,172.

2. Moderate year, $10,000 of care. Medigap stays at $5,085, because Plan G pays everything after the Part B deductible. Advantage: $2,513 + 20% x $10,000 = $4,513. Advantage still saves $572.

3. Major year, $50,000 of care (a hospital stay and follow-up). Medigap: still $5,085. Advantage: 20% x $50,000 = $10,000, capped at $9,850, so $2,513 + $9,850 = $12,363. Medigap saves $7,278. With high-deductible Plan G at $50 a month instead, the same year costs $2,513 + $600 + $480 + $3,050 = $6,643.

Break-even: Advantage costs $2,513 + 20% of care; Plan G costs a flat $5,085. They meet when 20% of care equals $2,572, at about $12,860 of care a year. A plan with a lower out-of-pocket maximum moves that point and shrinks the worst case, so use your plan's real numbers.

What the Numbers Leave Out

  • Getting Medigap later. Your best time to buy Medigap is your 6-month Medigap Open Enrollment Period, which starts the month you are 65 or older and have Part B. After that, insurers in most states can ask health questions and refuse you. That makes choosing Advantage at 65 harder to undo than the reverse.
  • Trial rights. If you join Medicare Advantage when you first get Medicare at 65, or drop a Medigap policy to try Advantage for the first time, you have 12 months to switch back with a guaranteed right to buy Medigap.
  • Networks and approvals. Advantage plans can require referrals and prior authorization, and out-of-network care may cost more or not be covered (except emergencies). If you split the year between states or want a specific cancer center, check networks first.
  • Extra benefits. Many Advantage plans include some dental, vision and hearing coverage that Original Medicare does not. Value them at what you would actually use.
  • Premium increases. Medigap premiums usually rise with age or inflation; Advantage premiums and copays can change every January. Review your plan's Annual Notice of Change each fall.
  • Drugs. Compare the actual drug costs of the Part D plan and the Advantage plan on Medicare Plan Finder; estimate them with the Medicare Part D cost calculator.

Key Dates for 2027 Coverage

  • October 15 to December 7, 2026: Medicare open enrollment. Switch between Original Medicare and Advantage or change plans; changes start January 1.
  • January 1 to March 31, 2027: if you are in an Advantage plan, you can switch to a different Advantage plan or to Original Medicare once.
  • Any time: you can apply for a Medigap policy, but outside guaranteed-issue situations the insurer may use medical underwriting.

Related

See what you will pay for Part B and any income surcharge with the Medicare Part B premium 2027 calculator, and read Medicare Part B Premium 2027. Medigap does not cover dental care; if dental benefits are part of your decision, compare the options with the dental insurance for seniors calculator.

Sources: CMS, Final Contract Year 2027 Standards for Part C Benefits, Bid Review and Evaluation (HPMS memo, April 22, 2026), Table 3; CMS, Deductible Amount for Medigap High Deductible Options F, G and J for Calendar Year 2027 (October 2026); CMS fact sheet, 2027 Medicare Parts A & B Premiums and Deductibles (November 17, 2026); CMS CY 2027 Rate Announcement (Part D); Medicare.gov, Medigap and Medicare Advantage guides. Estimates for planning only; your plan's costs and rules apply.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Medigap or Medicare Advantage better?

It depends on how much care you expect and how much you value choice. Medicare Advantage usually costs less in a healthy year because many plans charge no premium beyond Part B, but you pay copays as you use care, up to an out-of-pocket maximum (as high as $9,850 in network in 2027), and you are limited to the plan's network and rules. Medigap Plan G costs more each month but leaves you paying little beyond the $292 Part B deductible in 2027, with any doctor in the country who takes Medicare. In our example, Advantage is cheaper until care costs about $12,860 in a year.

What is the Medicare Advantage out-of-pocket maximum for 2027?

The federal limit is $9,850 for in-network Part A and Part B services, up from $9,250 in 2026. PPO plans can set a combined in- and out-of-network limit of up to $14,800. Many plans set lower limits; check your plan's Evidence of Coverage. Prescription drugs have a separate $2,400 cap, and premiums do not count toward either limit.

Can I switch from Medicare Advantage to Medigap later?

You can return to Original Medicare during open enrollment (October 15 to December 7) or the Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment Period (January 1 to March 31), but a Medigap insurer can usually turn you down or charge more because of your health once your 6-month Medigap Open Enrollment Period has passed, unless you have a guaranteed-issue right or live in a state with extra protections. Trial rights help: if you joined Medicare Advantage when you first got Medicare at 65, or dropped Medigap to try Advantage for the first time, you can switch back within 12 months with a guaranteed right to buy a Medigap policy.

What is the high-deductible Plan G deductible for 2027?

$3,050, up from $2,950 in 2026 (CMS, October 2026). You pay Medicare's cost sharing, including the Part B deductible, until you have paid $3,050; then the policy pays like regular Plan G. Premiums are usually much lower than regular Plan G.

Can you have Medigap and Medicare Advantage at the same time?

No. Medigap only works with Original Medicare and cannot pay Medicare Advantage copays or deductibles, and it is illegal for anyone to sell you a Medigap policy if they know you are in a Medicare Advantage plan. If you switch to Advantage, think carefully before dropping your Medigap policy, because you may not be able to buy it back later.

Do you still pay the Part B premium with Medicare Advantage?

Yes. You keep paying the Part B premium ($209.40 a month in 2027) plus any plan premium. Some plans offer a "Part B giveback" that reduces it. Higher earners also pay IRMAA either way; check yours with the Medicare IRMAA calculator.